Home Articles Reader Opinion Editorial Book Reviews Discussion Writers Guide About TCRecord
transparent 13
You Are Here: Read an Article > View All Posts for the Article > Read a Post
Read a Post for On the Spirit of Patriotism: Challenges of a “Pedagogy of Discomfort”
Reply to this Post

Comments from a New Zealander

Posted By: Karen Vaughan on September 11, 2002
Firstly, I'd like to thank both authors for raising the notion of a pedagogy of discomfort in relation to patriotism in the wake of September 11. The article provides a useful way for non-USers to think about the events, publicity, and activities since then.

While many, if not most, NZers are outraged and frightened by the terrorism directed at the US, and have extended friendship and support to the US, there is also much dismay, outrage, and fear over the actions of the United States' government. Those feelings can be placed in a context of a still rather uneasy relationship with the US, perhaps best exemplified by NZ's anti-nuclear stance and US repsonse of removing NZ from ANZUS, downgrading NZ from "ally" to "friend". A pedagogy of discomfort allows NZers to situate complex feelings about September 11 and its aftermath and (re)consider the NZ-US relationship in terms that allow us to think about the United States and the world generally beyond reactions to what may look like US arrogance, or assumptions about centrality of the United States, to being able to think about the citizens of the United States - as themselves struggling with how to think clearly about their response(s) to events and their place in the world. It's common for NZers to react to USers and forget that USers do not have all the answers (even if not everyone agrees with them); we ALL need to keep thinking and consider taking a lead ourselves.
Thread Hierarchy
 Comments from a New Zealander by Karen Vaughan on September 11, 2002
    Member Center
    In Print
    This Month's Issue