Topics

AdministrationViolenceSupervisionLeadership

Adult EducationCorp. Training and Continuing Ed.LiteracyTransformative Learning

Assessment & EvaluationProgram EvaluationAlternative AssessmentGradingStandardized Testing

Social ContextHistory of SchoolingPhilosophyUrban EducationEconomics and School-to-workRural EducationSociology of EducationWar and EducationPost-Industrial Education

CounselingSecondary SchoolsCollege Advising

CurriculumControlArtsSocial StudiesHealth and NutritionLanguage ArtsMathematicsPeace StudiesScience

DiversityRace and EthnicityAt-Risk StudentsSpecial NeedsGender and Sexuality

Early Childhood EducationPre-School and Child CareEarly Childhood Development

Higher EducationAdmissions and TuitionFacultyPolicyStudent and Community Life

International EducationComparative EducationEducational Development

LearningCognitionParental InfluenceEducational Psychology

PolicyReformCharters & VouchersHigh-Stakes TestingStandardsAthletes and AcademicsDropoutsIndependent SchoolsPhilanthropyPoliticsReligionTracking

Research MethodsQualitative MethodsSurvey ResearchExperimental ResearchLibrariesWriting for Publication

Teacher EducationProfessional DevelopmentSchools of EducationStudent Teaching

TeachingTeaching ProfessionSupply and DemandWorking Conditions

TechnologyTechnology in the ClassroomDistance LearningTechnology EducationPublishing and CommunicationOnline Publishing

IntersectionsPolicy and Teaching Practice

Discussion
Technology - Good for Students AND Teachers Fiddling with Indicators while using Toxic Tests Ode to Dewey Clearly Articulated Proposal--Thank You! VAM Sham BAM
more >>

Announcements

Call for Proposals: Best Practices in Teaching Critical Pedagogy Online

Call for proposals:The Journal of Social Studies Research

Call for Papers - Journal of Educational Controversy

Call for Editorial Team--Mid-Western Educational Researcher

make a post | more >>

Rhetoric Versus Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know About Vouchers and Charter Schools

reviewed by Christopher Nelson - 2003

Title: Rhetoric Versus Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know About Vouchers and Charter Schools
Author(s): Brian P. Gill, P. Michael Timpane, Karen E. Ross and Dominic Brewer
Publisher: Rand, Santa Monica, CA
ISBN: 0833027654, Pages: 120, Year: 2001
Search for book at Amazon.com

Debates about vouchers, charters, and other market-based school reforms tend to be confusing mixtures of data, ideology, politics, and constitutional argument.� Brian Gill, P. Michael Timpane, Karen Ross, and Dominic Brewer of RAND seek to provide insight into these debates through a systematic review of literature on vouchers and charter schools in their book, Rhetoric Versus Reality: What We Know and What We Need to Know About Vouchers and Charter Schools.� �Whether a system based on family choice undermines the values associated with the common school,� they write, �is an empirical question� (p. 201).� As the book�s title suggests, answers to these empirical questions (which involve achievement, access, integration, choice, and civic socialization) remain fraught with uncertainty.� Still the authors provide an illuminating attempt to relate current research � imperfect as it is � on the subject to the continuing policy debate on market-based educational reforms.� � The book begins with the issue of student achievement.� After bemoaning the dearth of high quality studies on the topic, the authors conclude... (preview truncated at 150 words.)

To view the full-text for this article you must be signed-in with the appropriate membership. Please review your options below:

Cite This Article as: Teachers College Record Volume 105 Number 4, 2003, p. 639-642
http://www.tcrecord.org ID Number: 11016, Date Accessed: 3/20/2019 6:08:12 PM

Purchase Reprint Rights for this article or review

Article Tools
Email this article Print this article Post a Comment

Related Discussion

Post a Comment \| Read All

About the Author
Christopher Nelson The Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University E-mail Author CHRISTOPHER NELSON is a senior research associate at The Evaluation Center, Western Michigan University, where he has authored and contributed to large-scale evaluations of charter schools in five states. He is co-author of a recent book on Michigan charter schools and is currently completing a number of scholarly papers on charter school teachers, student achievement, and the correlates of success in charter schools. Along with education reform, Nelson works on issues related to evaluation methodology and public policy. Nelson holds a B.A. from the University of Minnesota and an M.A. and Ph.D. from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Member Center
	Welcome! Sign-in Submit My Work TCR @ Your Library Book Reviews @ Your Library

In Print

This Month's Issue
Back Issues: