Subscribe today to the most trusted name in education.  Learn more.
Current Issue Current Issue Subscriptions About TCRecord Advanced Search   

 

The Blaine Game: Are Public Schools Inherently Anti-Catholic?


by Benjamin Justice

Background/Context: Conservative jurists and scholars have reached the conclusion that the traditional separation of public funding from religious organizations in K-12 education was “born of bigotry,” and inherently anti-Catholic. This claim rests on the misuse of revisionist historical interpretations that emphasize ethno-cultural conflict to the exclusion of widespread political understandings about republican government and the compatibility of the (then) anti-republican Vatican.

Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study: This study questions the claim that public education is inherently anti-Catholic by focusing on the meaning of anti-Catholicism in two key historical periods in the development of public education.

Research Design: The study draws on historical documents from New York State as a case study, but also draws on other sources, primary and secondary, from the ante- and post-bellum periods of the nineteenth century.

Conclusions/Recommendations: The article argues that while the development of the public school was un-catholic, in the sense that it did not give Catholic Church authorities what they wanted, its development was not the result of bigotry, but rather of concern about the proper governance of mass education in a republic. It concludes that scholars and judges should engage in more sophisticated analysis of the past, rather than resorting to the casual use of terms like “bigotry” and “anti-Catholicism.”

Cite This Article as: Teachers College Record Volume 109 Number 9, 2007, p. 2171-2206
http://www.tcrecord.org/library ID Number: 14481, Date Accessed: 9/25/2017 4:29:48 PM


Catch the latest video from AfterEd, the new video channel from the EdLab at Teachers College.
Global education news of the week in brief.; NCLB; international education; software; This episode explores ten interesting and little known facts about Social Studies.; social studies; humor; media; research; schools; Three seniors at Heritage High School talk about education and what the next President should do about it.; Debates; Heritage High School; NCLB; NYC schools; education; election; girls; interview; politics; presidential election; schools; speak out; students; testing; EdWorthy Theater starring MIT Physics Professor Professor Walter Lewin.; MIT; physics; We feature new content about the future of education. Put us on your website ­ whether you're a student, teacher, or educational institution, we aim to create great content that will entertain and enlighten your audience. http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1078591423http://www.brightcove.com/channel.jsp?channel=1079000717

Site License Agreement    
 Get statistics in Counter format