Does Publish or Perish Academic Culture Foster Intellectual Vice?
by Mark J. Ortwein, Stacey Britton & Amber Carpenter-McCullough — March 28, 2014
In this commentary, we suggest that the contemporary publish-or-perish academic culture stands to negatively impact pre-tenure professors—particularly professors at R1 institutions. Indeed, we believe that the present overemphasis on publication, and its attending de-emphasis on teaching quality and meaningful service, provides rich soil for the cultivation of intellectual dereliction. To this end, we assert that the development of “intellectual virtue” ought to be a primary aim of doctoral and pre-tenure mentorship. Such virtues include intellectual honesty, conscientiousness, creativity, and open-mindedness. We conclude the piece with some remarks on cultivating intellectual virtue in the academy.
To view the full-text for this article you must be signed-in with the appropropriate membership. Please review your options below: