Home Articles Reader Opinion Editorial Book Reviews Discussion Writers Guide About TCRecord
transparent 13
Assessment & Evaluation

by Jonathan Supovitz — 2013
Design-based implementation research offers the opportunity to rethink the relationships between intervention, research, and situation to better attune research and evaluation to the program development process. Using a heuristic called the intervention development curve, I describe the rough trajectory that programs typically follow as they evolve, and argue that research design considerations and methodological choices are best made in consideration of where interventions are along this curve. Further, I contend that, as programs develop, situational influences play a major role in their evolution and consequently require increased attention to design and methodological considerations. By viewing research as an integral part of a program’s development, by making design and methodological choices in consideration of where programs are in their development, and by considering that the situation in which programs evolve as a potential source of change in the nature of the program itself, we alter fundamental perspectives on how research can best contribute to the steady work of building robust programs for educational improvement.

by Eva Baker — 2013
This article approaches the evolving concept of validity of assessments, moving from the scholarship of the past, to the constraints and demands of the present. The use of technology and globalization are raised as challenges to future approaches to validity.

by Leo Casey — 2013
This article provides an analysis of the recent publication of the value-added measurements found in the Teacher Data Reports of the New York City Department of Education.

by David Steiner — 2013
This article considers the value of the national move toward value-added measures and our current fascination with objective measurements – a fascination that stems from our collective distrust of our teachers and ourselves, and our reluctance to make judgments about the substantive narratives we teach students.

by Kevin Welner — 2013
Assessment use has switched from measurement tools to policy levers. Meaning is created by use, and the intense push for test-based accountability and teacher evaluation policies in the U.S. has fundamentally changed the nature of test use. The core meaning of testing has accordingly been qualitatively changed, and serious policy attention to issues of consequential validity counsels against use of tests to drive policy unless, and until, the results that process itself have been validated for their furtherance of recognized goals.

by Lorrie Shepard — 2013
This article, an afterword to the special issue, considers the multiple purposes of test validity.

by Bethany Rogers & Megan Blumenreich — 2013
This research uses oral history narratives to examine the professional choices and trajectories of Teach for America participants over a twenty-year period, attending especially to individuals’ perceptions of their urban teaching experiences, their beliefs, and their reasons for staying in or leaving the urban classroom, with the aim of better understanding the experiences of such teachers and the implications for staffing urban schools.

by Kevin Dougherty, Rebecca Natow, Rachel Bork, Sosanya Jones & Blanca Vega — 2013
Examination of the political origins of state performance funding for higher education in six states (Florida, Illinois, Missouri, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Washington) and the lack of its development in another two states (California and Nevada).

by Erica Turner & Cynthia E. Coburn — 2012
Setting the stage for the special issue, this article discusses the increased attention to data use in policy and practice, provides an overview of the major ways that scholars have studied data use, highlights the limitations of the extant research, summarizes the contributions of the articles in this special issue to addressing these limitations, and previews the articles that follow.

by Jonathan Supovitz — 2012
This article reviews the literature on the qualities of assessments and identifies three crucial test design elements that can provide insightful feedback to teachers about students’ understanding to inform subsequent instructional choices.

by Julie Marsh — 2012
This article synthesizes what we currently know about interventions to support educators’ use of data—ranging from comprehensive, system-level initiatives, such as reforms sponsored by districts or intermediary organizations, to more narrowly focused interventions, such as a workshop. The article summarizes what is known across studies about the design and implementation of these interventions, their effects at the individual and organizational levels, and the conditions shown to affect implementation and outcomes, and concludes by suggesting directions for future research.

by Jennifer Jennings — 2012
Many studies have found that educational accountability policies increase data use, but because accountability has been conceived of as one “treatment,” little is known about the features of accountability systems that are most likely to increase desirable versus undesirable uses of data. I define desirable data use as practices that do not invalidate the inferences about student- and school-level performance that policy makers, educators, and parents hope to make. This article proposes that five features of accountability systems affect how data are used and discusses what we know, and what we don’t know, about their effects. In each of these areas, I propose a research agenda intended to further our understanding of how accountability systems affect data use.

by Alan Daly — 2012
This article offers that many data use studies suggest that the interpretation and use of data take place both within and between individuals who, through social interaction, are both co-constructing and making sense of data and their use. Given the increasing important role of social relationships in data use studies, better theorizing and deeper understanding regarding the dynamics of social influence and processes on the interpretation and use of data are needed. Social network theory and analysis offers a useful conceptual framework and accompanying methods for describing and analyzing the structure of a social system in an effort to understand how social relationships support and constrain the interpretation and use of data in educational improvement.

by Jeffrey Henig — 2012
This article reviews political science theories and findings to inform our understanding of how politics affects efforts to increase data usage in education policy and school reform. Rather than block the door to politics, those who hope to promote informed policy making might consider ways to use politics to protect and defend high-quality data.

by Janet Weiss — 2012
This commentary on the special issue on data use highlights the distinctions between data systems intended to improve the performance of school staff and those intended to hold schools and districts accountable for outcomes. It advises researchers to be alert to the differences in the policy logics connected with each approach.

by Warren Simmons — 2012
This commentary draws on the articles in this issue to underscore the importance of community engagement and districtwide capacity building as central to efforts to use data to inform accountability and choice, along with school and instructional improvement. The author cautions against treating data as an all-purpose tool absent adequate attention to developing solutions to the problems data illuminate.

by Melissa Roderick — 2012
This commentary frames the importance of the topic of this special issue by highlighting the changes that have occurred in school systems around data use, particularly in large urban districts, and the need for a more rigorous evidence base. Collectively, the articles in this volume provide a jumping-off point for such a research agenda around data use in schools. Each of the articles identifies significant gaps in our knowledge base and develops useful conceptual frameworks within which to think about the dimensions of data use, the quality of the research evidence, and the implications for the field.

by Stuart Rojstaczer & Christopher Healy — 2012
College grades can influence a student’s graduation prospects, academic motivation, postgraduate job choice, professional and graduate school selection, and access to loans and scholarships. Despite the importance of grades, national trends in grading practices have not been examined in over a decade, and there has been a limited effort to examine the historical evolution of college grading. This article looks at the evolution of grading over time and space at American colleges and universities over the last 70 years. The data provide a means to examine how instructors’ assessments of excellence, mediocrity, and failure have changed in higher education.

by Julian Vasquez Heilig — 2011
This study examines the impact of high-stakes exit testing on English learners (ELs) in Texas. Quantitative and qualitative data suggest that high-stakes exit assessments have led to higher EL dropout and lower graduation rates.

by Henry Braun, Irwin Kirsch & Kentaro Yamamoto — 2011
This article describes a randomized field trial conducted to estimate the impact of modest monetary incentives on performance on a version of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) 12th-grade reading assessment. Monetary incentives have a statistically significant and substantively important impact on both student engagement/effort and achievement.

by Elizabeth Graue & Erica Johnson — 2011
The goal of this article is to broaden the understanding of what it means for schools and teachers to be held accountable for student learning and to discuss how different accountability frameworks affect instructional practices in classrooms. We take a practice-oriented perspective on assessment, examining how assessments in schools that participated in a class size reduction program intersected with forces of accountability. Building on three years of data collection in 27 classrooms in nine schools, data were generated through multiple methods, including ethnographic observations, interviews, administration of the Classroom Assessment Scoring System (CLASS), document and artifact collection, and analyses of school-level standardized test scores. We identify and discuss three aspects of assessment practices that affect this intersection: alignment, audience, and action.

by Geraldine McDonald — 2010
This article argues that the historical reduction of age at grade level in the 20th century has interacted with test scores that take age into account, resulting in a rise in IQ scores in school populations.

by William Penuel — 2010
This chapter contrasts the approach to educational evaluation championed in recent educational policy-making with a dialogical epistemology of evaluation. A dialogical epistemology, drawn from the writings of M. M. Bakhtin, enjoins evaluators to consider multiple voices and their relative authority and power in making judgments of the worth or merit of programs. Further, it positions them as participants in policy discussions rather than arbiters of program value whose authority stems from the methods they use.

by Robert Bullough, Jr. — 2010
Framed by the assumptions of ethnomethodology and drawing on methods of conversational analysis, the author analyzed a set of 10 transcripts of Teacher Work Sample scoring conversations to identify patterns in scorer interaction. Interactive rules and strategies are identified and implications and cautions offered for the use of work samples, particularly for high-stakes assessment.

by Frances Rust — 2009
In this article, teacher action research is positioned as a bridge connecting research, practice, and policy—as an important and practical way to engage teachers as consumers of research, as researchers of their own practice, as designers of their own professional development, and as informants to scholars and policy-makers regarding critical issues in the field.

by John S. Wills & Judith Haymore Sandholtz — 2009
This article analyzes the classroom instruction of an experienced teacher in an elementary school where the principal resisted a movement toward standardization and supported teachers’ autonomy and authority over curriculum and instruction amid high-stakes state-level testing in language arts and mathematics. Examining the teacher’s instructional practice in social studies, a subject not included in state testing but nevertheless impacted by state testing, we demonstrate how specific teaching dilemmas that arose in response to state testing led to a new type of professional practice that we call constrained professionalism.

by Bryan A. Brown — 2008
This project examines the intersection of in-class assessments, student identity, and the construction of teachable moments. Through examining a science department’s attempt to use daily practice with assessments as a teaching tool, this study explored students’ use of discourse in relation to the teacher’s use of this approach to teaching.

by Ann Ryan & Alan Stoskopf — 2008
This article focuses on the public and Catholic school discourse that accompanied the introduction of IQ testing in the early 20th century. It analyzes the nature of the discourse among educational researchers, administrators, and teachers in two parallel educational settings and examines the way that public and Catholic school educators responded to IQ testing.

by Christine Sleeter — 2008
This article contrasts democracy with corporatocracy, showing that the accountability movement today is rooted more in the latter than the former. Case studies of two teachers explore how democratically minded teachers can navigate accountability pressures in a corporatocratic context, as well as limitations that context places on them.

by Christina Madda, Richard Halverson & Louis Gomez — 2007
This study explores the design process of how one urban school district developed and deployed a series of reports designed to communicate the results of student achievement testing across the district. The focus of this research is to understand the district’s efforts to design new programs that would fit coherently into existing initiatives in local schools.

Found 341
Displaying 31 to 60
<Back | Next>
Recent Posts
Book Reviews
by W. Holmes Finch, Jason C. Immekus, & Brian F. French
reviwed by Marshall Beauchamp — 2017

by Stewart I. Donaldson & Robert Picciotto (Eds.)
reviwed by Robert Reardon — 2016

by Hong Jiao & Robert W. Lissitz (Eds.)
reviwed by Jaehwa Choi & Jaekyung Lee — 2016

by Stafford Hood, Rodney Hopson & Henry Frierson
reviwed by Dhani Shah — 2016

by Jason A. Grissom and Peter Youngs
reviwed by Tarek Azzam — 2016

by Ying Cheng, Hua-Hua Chang (Eds.)
reviwed by Todd Reeves — 2016

by Todd Stanley
reviwed by Kendall Hartley & Cynthia Clark — 2015

by Linda Darling-Hammond & Frank Adamson
reviwed by Arlo Kempf — 2015

by Margaret Heritage
reviwed by Randall Davies — 2015

Found 148
Displaying 1 to 10
<Back | Next>

Found 67Displaying 1 to 10 Next>
Member Center
In Print
This Month's Issue